PDA

View Full Version : May Smeargle's Art Challenge Voting


HKim
05-28-2005, 04:55 PM
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v90/Phoenix6288/sac.gif
- Thanks to Matthew for the banner.


Welcome to the voting of Smeargle's Art Challenge!

Remember you may only vote for one entry. Pick the one that you feel best represents the theme: War Banner. In addition, judge on the artistry of the piece. Voting ends June 4th.

The top three artists will be honored in the PE2K Art Museum. In addition, the top artist will have his banner featured as the official banner for War Season 4 as well as win $5000 in URPG money. I wish all of our entering members good luck!

Now it's time to vote!



Entries

Entry 1
http://www.imghst.com/uploads/sjklakesuccess/Abstract6_01.pnghttp://www.imghst.com/uploads/sjklakesuccess/Abstract6_02.gif
http://www.imghst.com/uploads/sjklakesuccess/Abstract6_03.png
http://www.imghst.com/uploads/sjklakesuccess/Abstract6_04.pnghttp://img194.echo.cx/img194/7697/abstract6054iy.gifhttp://www.imghst.com/uploads/sjklakesuccess/Abstract6_06.png
Title: War IV
Artist: SSK1911


Entry 2
http://img102.echo.cx/my.php?image=warseasonv27oo.swf
Title: War Season V
Artist: Rukario


Entry 3
http://www.hostpicsfree.info/115348warbanner2800.gif
Title: War Season 4 Banner
Artist: Bronislav84


Entry 4
http://img151.echo.cx/img151/7346/warcopy3qe.jpg
Title: War Banner
Artist: Defense.2


Entry 5
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v205/DaMightea1/48aac247.gif
Title: War Season IV
Artist: Pigeot79


Entry 6
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v205/DaMightea1/86b3ddde.png
Title: War Season IV
Artist: Pigeot79


Entry 7
http://img290.echo.cx/img290/1927/warseasoniv3cl.gif
Title: War Season IV
Artist: Defense.2

Incongruity
05-28-2005, 04:58 PM
harry, mine is not just one image. It's sliced into many. Just quote my post where I did it and edit out the other text

image edited out to save bandwith


can I vote for myself? :tongue: :wink:

HKim
05-28-2005, 05:04 PM
harry, mine is not just one image. It's sliced into many. Just quote my post where I did it and edit out the other text

http://www.imghst.com/uploads/sjklakesuccess/Abstract6_01.pnghttp://www.imghst.com/uploads/sjklakesuccess/Abstract6_02.gif
http://www.imghst.com/uploads/sjklakesuccess/Abstract6_03.png
http://www.imghst.com/uploads/sjklakesuccess/Abstract6_04.pnghttp://img194.echo.cx/img194/7697/abstract6054iy.gifhttp://www.imghst.com/uploads/sjklakesuccess/Abstract6_06.png

can I vote for myself? :tongue: :wink:


Okay, thanks for the information. I'll go and fix it.

You have the right to vote for yourself if you want to.

Caite-chan
05-28-2005, 06:02 PM
I voted for SK's.

Matthew
05-28-2005, 07:07 PM
SK wins *blah blah blah*

I also liked D2's last entry... but sk's was just better.... :rolleyes:

Nefarious
05-28-2005, 07:13 PM
Hmm...I really like sk's but for some reason I like D.2's better. They both fade the names of the teams which is a very nice addition. So I guess D.2 gets my vote.

Pikachu
05-28-2005, 10:07 PM
I voted for P79's. The first one by SK is cool but it's pretty dark. I thought something a little brighter would be more appropriate. :wink:

Matt
05-29-2005, 08:37 PM
Harry, the theme still says science.

HKim
05-29-2005, 08:54 PM
Harry, the theme still says science.


Thanks for the input. I changed it.

Jack of Clovers
05-30-2005, 12:47 AM
the fonts are either small or hard to read. bleh.

i guess entry 7 wins my vote.

~Jack~

Exon Auxus
05-30-2005, 01:28 AM
I vote D.2. That was a creative way of getting all of the W.A.R. teams on his banner. GO D.2!

Neo Emolga
05-30-2005, 03:07 AM
SK's. Defense's second banner comes quite close though.

Sweet job on that one.

Hoenn Mirror Girl
05-30-2005, 03:40 AM
Entry 7
http://img290.echo.cx/img290/1927/warseasoniv3cl.gif
Title: War Season IV
Artist: Defense.2
I'm in love with this one.

Thanatos
05-30-2005, 07:10 AM
Vote: Sk.

Awesome stuff ^_^

Channel Delibird
05-30-2005, 10:27 AM
I voted for P79's second one (I think when they're so similar they should be one vote >_>). All the others seemed very dark and not exactly capturing the feeling of fun, which I think should be the core of the whole thing. P79's was light, bright and beautfiul. Go P79, w00t!

Matt
05-30-2005, 11:40 AM
Brighness should be the core of a war? I got the impression that war was dark and painful, and that's what I based mine arouund.

Channel Delibird
05-30-2005, 02:24 PM
Brighness should be the core of a war? I got the impression that war was dark and painful, and that's what I based mine arouund.

I meant that the spirit of the competition was to have fun. Actually calling it the 'War' was just to make it sound cool. X_X We don't encourage death on this forum...

Incongruity
05-30-2005, 02:43 PM
Brighness should be the core of a war? I got the impression that war was dark and painful, and that's what I based mine arouund.
which is the reason I suppose there's a huge flower to the left :susp:

and to the person who voted for D.2 for the way he blended the teams, that deserves another :susp:

i'll vote in a bit

Matt
05-30-2005, 04:09 PM
But it's an evil flower...eh...I don't know, it seemed to fit. It's still dismal. As for the names fading, I didn't notice you did it until NF pointed it out. I was too busy looking at the scrolling text. I greatly apologize.

May's Secret love
06-01-2005, 03:13 AM
Pickacho Sit!

Matt
06-01-2005, 10:50 AM
Who voted for Rukario? His banner says season five, this is season four.

Umbreon Shadow
06-01-2005, 09:03 PM
i voted for Bronislav84

Pidgeot79
06-03-2005, 12:16 AM
Well I did the un-noble thing and voted for myself. :angel:

Incongruity
06-03-2005, 12:35 AM
alright, now that someone else has already done it, I too will vote for myself :razz:


if I wasn't a selfish ass, I would have voted for either P79 or D.2's second banner. However, P79's text is kind of weird, bg too bright for me (i'm opposite of vex) and stock is meh. overall it looks good though. D.2's just seemed to random for me, and the diagonal scan lines didn't help. I didn't like the text on this either.


but I am a selfish ass

TotodileHop24
06-03-2005, 04:20 AM
Wow, this was a hard decision for me. I totally loved sk's entry... but I loved Pidgeot's 1st entry as well. While I thought the bright blue background with a faded Rayquaza looked really awesome together, the text was a bit too hard to read. sk's was a little more noticeable, and it was made better by adding a fainted Deoyxs and an animated scroll of the WAR teams. Both had everything well organized throughout the banner. A close one, but sk wins my vote.

Great work on all of the entries! :clap:

Pidgeot79
06-03-2005, 06:17 AM
alright, now that someone else has already done it, I too will vote for myself :razz:


if I wasn't a selfish ass, I would have voted for either P79 or D.2's second banner. However, P79's text is kind of weird, bg too bright for me (i'm opposite of vex) and stock is meh. overall it looks good though. D.2's just seemed to random for me, and the diagonal scan lines didn't help. I didn't like the text on this either.


but I am a selfish ass

Lol, I was going to wait for somebody too, but I decided not to incase I forgot.

Dragon Lover
06-03-2005, 07:26 AM
I think Bonislav's banner fits the war the best.

~DL~

Raddstealth316
06-03-2005, 10:11 PM
Sk has the style and class, but...

It does not suit for a title banner for the war, and for that D2 wins for me. *votes*