Gotta Catch em' all Johto: Gold and Silver Voting Poll/Discussion - Pokemon Forum

Judge Dredd · #1 08-30-2012, 02:20 AM

Gotta Catch em' All is coming back in a big way. The Gold and Silver Edition maybe coming soon with there own wifi giveaway! Before they come back, I wanted to get a gauge interest on them. I am posting a poll and I would like your help to decide what to do. If interest is very low I will only be opening Gold or Silver. I would also like your feedback on them. If you didnt join Red or Blue Id like to know why? What changes would like to see? What did Red and Blue miss that would make you join Gold and Silver ?

brandon_g · #2 08-30-2012, 02:23 AM

I thought everything seemed good already... but i am sure there is always room for improvements... the wifi giveaway might work..

Judge Dredd · #3 08-30-2012, 02:25 AM

Now I added the poll ...lol

Neku Sakuraba · #4 08-30-2012, 02:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Judge Dredd

Now I added the poll ...lol

That rhymed...xD Anyways, I think a Gold/Silver GCeA would be nice. I didn't join because I kinda forgot about it because of school and stuffs...I would join and be active on this one, though!

5TailedDemonLizard · #5 08-30-2012, 03:02 AM

I would join, for sure! I love the second generation to bits. Hopefully I'll still be able to be active despite school.

Judge Dredd · #6 08-30-2012, 03:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Metal Gear Snivy

That rhymed...xD Anyways, I think a Gold/Silver GCeA would be nice. I didn't join because I kinda forgot about it because of school and stuffs...I would join and be active on this one, though!

Well it would be a good way to start with the others if you wanted.

Quote:

Originally Posted by 5TailedDemonLizard

I would join, for sure! I love the second generation to bits. Hopefully I'll still be able to be active despite school.

Thanks for the feedback ! Make sure you vote! Im going to be using this poll to

5TailedDemonLizard · #7 08-30-2012, 03:29 AM

Perhaps you could start off with several different rewards since some people (like me) aren't able to get wi-fi and therefore couldn't participate in the wi-fi giveaway.

Judge Dredd · #8 08-30-2012, 05:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 5TailedDemonLizard

Perhaps you could start off with several different rewards since some people (like me) aren't able to get wi-fi and therefore couldn't participate in the wi-fi giveaway.

what is something that you would like ? maybe a special pokemon to use in the game ??

Typhlosion Explosion · #9 08-30-2012, 05:19 PM

I should get a Cyndaquil lol jk (or not if I really get one) X3.

Anyways, I think activity is good enough to start.

Judge Dredd · #10 08-30-2012, 05:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Typhlosion Explosion

I should get a Cyndaquil lol jk (or not if I really get one) X3.

Anyways, I think activity is good enough to start.

Well TDL suggested giving out stuff to people who dont have wifi, any thoughts?

Typhlosion Explosion · #11 08-30-2012, 05:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Judge Dredd

Well TDL suggested giving out stuff to people who dont have wifi, any thoughts?

That could be a great idea. Like giving out Johto Starters.

brandon_g · #12 08-30-2012, 05:55 PM

Well this is just a thought... Why not at some point during the game give people the chance to catch rare pokemon from another region that would be a real treat, but again you should save it for when a good oppurinty appears.

Judge Dredd · #13 08-30-2012, 06:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Typhlosion Explosion

That could be a great idea. Like giving out Johto Starters.

well I was planning on giving those out on wifi, maybe I can offer people a starter from another reason as a treat.

Quote:

Originally Posted by brandon_g

Well this is just a thought... Why not at some point during the game give people the chance to catch rare pokemon from another region that would be a real treat, but again you should save it for when a good oppurinty appears.

Legendary pokemon are still a work in progress, this slight RP treats them like tv series does...They appear but cant really be caught.

Latio-Nytro · #14 08-30-2012, 08:47 PM

They (the Legends) technically can be caught-a few trainers had actually caught Legendary Pokemon in the canon anime, Brandon being a particuarily noteworthy example (True to his in-Game appearance, he had all three Legendary Golems). I also know that Dredd plans to (near the end of Red and Blue) have individual campaigns to snag the Legendary Birds.

That being said, I would not open it "NOW," unless Red and Blue are both failing horribly (and right now, the latter has got a surge of activity.) However, a double-version, like before, could be used and I highly support that. Though, I would actually have the two teams inhibit the same plane of space and time this go-around (if Red and Blue have fixed that up), if only because battles between rival teams of trainers would be absolutely awesome...And Dredd can no longer have the ability to be in two places at once. Yes, I consider him being in Blue and Red and being able post there and catch Mon's in both absolutley cheating, personally.

As for a giveaway...Meh. I don't personall utilize Wi-Fi, though I might for this occasion.

Judge Dredd · #15 08-30-2012, 09:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Latio-Nytro

They (the Legends) technically can be caught-a few trainers had actually caught Legendary Pokemon in the canon anime, Brandon being a particuarily noteworthy example (True to his in-Game appearance, he had all three Legendary Golems). I also know that Dredd plans to (near the end of Red and Blue) have individual campaigns to snag the Legendary Birds.

That being said, I would not open it "NOW," unless Red and Blue are both failing horribly (and right now, the latter has got a surge of activity.) However, a double-version, like before, could be used and I highly support that. Though, I would actually have the two teams inhibit the same plane of space and time this go-around (if Red and Blue have fixed that up), if only because battles between rival teams of trainers would be absolutely awesome...And Dredd can no longer have the ability to be in two places at once. Yes, I consider him being in Blue and Red and being able post there and catch Mon's in both absolutley cheating, personally.

As for a giveaway...Meh. I don't personall utilize Wi-Fi, though I might for this occasion.

I wasnt suppose to be in blue mr calls me a cheater! I took over because TE wasnt keeping it going. What I will do if I end in both is separate pokemon I caught in one from pokemon I caught in another. Also you remember I keep the story going, and create new ideas...Its not very easy to keep two different stories moving with people switching out. Either way I have an idea for Gold and Silver as to how it could work where people could show up in each others threads for battles or side mission. I plan on keeping the two teams separate though.

Also, One of the Nurse Joys has a latias, and starting gold or silver would have nothing to do with red or blue. There are members who have expressed interest that dont want to try and catch up. I honestly would like to see some new faces in gold and silver. Of course the current people are encouraged to join, but honestly i wanted more people that missed out to join in.